I DON’T LOSE WHEN THE MARKET IS BAD? Tell me more….
I wonder how many people truly understand an Indexing Strategy in an insurance based environment?
We’ve all been educated about Indexing Strategies in mutual funds, ETF’s and so on. But as a rule, people have very little knowledge when it comes to insurance indexing strategies—yet they do exist. What’s more, the money in these assets grows tax free—like a 401 (k) – and can be accessed through policy loans, thus avoiding income taxes and allowing constant liquidity throughout the life of the assets.
So what exactly is an Indexing Strategy in an insurance based environment? This kind of strategy has two key components: a CAP or limit as to how much you can earn when the market is good and a protective floor of ZERO when the market is not good. How is this different to the S&P Index? The S&P Index spreads the investments evenly between 500 different stock companies. There’s no cap, so it lets you keep all the gains when the market is good, but when the market is bad, you suffer the loss.
Now look at the chart below. This illustrates how a total of $100,000 would have performed during the period 1998-2015 based on these two strategies. The top line of the graph represents the Insurance Indexing Strategy: you can see that in the years where the market loses money, you’re protected from losses due to the floor which protects principle. The same doesn’t apply if you’re invested in the market—where you’re subject to the lows as well as the highs of the S&P 500 Index. You can see that over time your assets in the Indexed Strategy are protected from loss and have the potential for substantial growth. Over the 17 year period 1998-2015, the total yield of the Indexing Strategy was 114.9% with an effective yield of 6.75% compared to the total yield of the S&P 500 Index which ended at 83% (effective yield 4.88%).
As a point of note a Nominal yield is what one makes on an annual basis (Bank paying 1 % annually on a CD is a nominal yield). An Effective yield: what one earns over a period of time greater than one year (for example, earnings of 5% in Year 1, 7% in Year 2 and 12% in Year 3 gives an effective yield of 24% over 3 years).
Over the 17 year period 1998-2015, the effective yield of the Indexing Strategy was 6.75% while the effective yield of the S&P 500 Index was 4.88%
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!